September 19, 2006 8:03 PM
Fantasy Investing: The Ugly Reality
My take is fantasy investing at best teaches you what is a put option vs a call option, but don't confuse yourself with limited success in fantasy investing with true investing talent.
From WSJ:
As online brokerages and other financial-services firms roll out new virtual-trading tools that promise to teach the ins and outs of complex investing strategies, some individual investors are finding the transition from fantasy trades to real-life investing isn't always a smooth one.
Indeed, investors' results in virtual accounts may be far different than their experience in the real market, since virtual programs often give investors unlimited sums of make-believe cash to trade with, encourage users to test their strategies with historical data that may not reflect current conditions and can't factor in the emotions that come in to play with real money.
...
While virtual-trading programs don't involve real money, these tools can pose their own risks, industry experts say. Many people use the programs as a springboard to making real trades. And while companies that offer virtual trading say these programs accurately simulate market conditions, investors can still encounter potentially costly surprises when they leave the land of make-believe.
"Virtual trading is a very powerful tool for investors, but its one limitation is that it will never be able to simulate the emotions involved in trading with real money," says optionsXpress Chief Executive David Kalt. "For that reason, we encourage investors to use our virtual-trading service...to gain experience with the many tools we offer to manage risk and limit the impact of emotion."
Given the differences between virtual-trading platforms and real market conditions, though, some experts question just how educational the programs are. "If I were an investor I would be very careful about using a trading simulator" to measure the success of a trading strategy, says Christopher Musto, an analyst at Keynote Systems Inc., an online-performance-measurement firm.
11/26/06 | Is Anheuser-Busch (BUD) A Buy?
11/25/06 | How To Buy QQQQ Without Commission
11/16/06 | Kraft (KFT) Spin-Off At Altria (MO) Is Near
11/04/06 | Stock Holdings By Our Congressmen
11/03/06 | What Does A Democrats' Win Mean To Your Financial Life?
11/01/06 | Warren Buffett Loves Retailing
11/01/06 | Six Banks May Receive Triple-A Credit Rating
10/31/06 | The Cash Machine at Exxon
10/31/06 | Wisdom from Value Investing Legend Christopher Browne
10/28/06 | Invest With Margin Loan? Use It At Your Own Risk
10/27/06 | Basics of Option Trading
10/26/06 | What Is Buy-And-Hold?
10/25/06 | The Difference Between Full Service and Discount Brokerage
10/25/06 | What Is P/E Ratio?
10/25/06 | Profitting From Penny Storys
10/23/06 | Go, PPD, Go!
10/22/06 | Should Microsoft (MSFT) Buy Yahoo (YHOO)?
10/22/06 | The Priceless Heart Attack
10/21/06 | Berkshire Hathaway And Its $100,000 Stock
10/20/06 | The World's Biggest IPO: Industrial & Commercial Bank of China (ICBC)
10/17/06 | Bill Gates' Successful Drug Investment
10/14/06 | Is BofA's Free Trading Program A Good Deal?
10/11/06 | What Is A Unit Investment Trust (UIT)?
10/11/06 | Visa Is Contemplating IPO
10/11/06 | Google Docs & Spreadsheets: Word and Excel From Google
10/10/06 | Will Fed Continue To Hike Interest Rates?
10/10/06 | MSN Money: 50 Best Stocks In The World
10/10/06 | Big Tobacco Companies Spending Big To Fight State Taxes (RAI, MO)
10/10/06 | Stocks With Dividend Growth Potentials (GE, MSFT, NI)
10/10/06 | Silver Linings Of Housing Industry (DHI, PHM, CTX, LEN, KBH, MDC, MTH)
10/09/06 | Berkshire Hathaway (BRK) Adds Its USG Corporation (USG) Stake
10/09/06 | China's ICBC On Track To Complete The Largest IPO, Ever
10/08/06 | How To Select Your Broker?
10/08/06 | What Is Day Trading?
10/08/06 | How To Get Corporate Reports?
10/08/06 | How To Avoid Internet Investment Scams
10/08/06 | Major Advantages Of Options Trading
10/08/06 | Basics of Stock Option Trading
10/08/06 | What Is A Stock Split?
10/08/06 | What Is A Reverse Split?
10/08/06 | What Happens To A Company After Bankruptcy?
10/08/06 | Hedge Short Selling Losses By Call Options
10/08/06 | 40,000 Starbucks (SBUX) Stores?
10/06/06 | Google (GOOG) To Acquire YouTube?
10/06/06 | How Mid-Term Election Will Affect Drug Companies
10/06/06 | Berkshire Hathaway (BRK) Breaks $100,000
10/04/06 | Is Qualcomm (QCOM) A Buy?
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: General Electric (GE)
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: FPL Group (FPL)
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: Anadarko Petroleum (APC)
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: J.P. Morgan Chase (JPM)
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: Burlington Northern (BNI)
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: Procter & Gamble (PG)
10/03/06 | Stocks For The Long Run: Applied Materials (AMAT)
10/03/06 | How To Make A Fortune In The Stock Market?
10/03/06 | Stock 101: Market Order, Limit Order And Stop Order
10/03/06 | What Is Dow Worth Today?
10/03/06 | First Data Spins Off Western Union
10/03/06 | The Motley Fool To Measure Stock Pickers
09/30/06 | Bank of America: Interest Rate Play
09/27/06 | Investment Managers Thinks U.S. Stock Markets Undervalued
09/26/06 | Microsoft To Broadcast Concerts Online
09/25/06 | Judge Certifies Class-Action Lawsuit of "Light Cigarette" Smokers
09/19/06 | How To Pick A Stock Broker?
09/19/06 | Fortune 40: The Best Stocks To Buy Now
09/19/06 | How To Buy Stocks?
09/19/06 | Bottom-Fishing For Energy Stocks?
09/15/06 | The Long Case for Pre-Paid Legal Services
09/14/06 | Full-Service Broker Or Discount Broker
09/12/06 | 14 Stocks for Retirement
09/11/06 | Just Purchased: ConocoPhillips (COP) @ $58.50